Transparency in Scholarly Book Publishing: How PRISM Connects Peer Review and Open Access

Jordy Findanis

Tue 17 Nov 2026

Read this article at hypothèses.org

Making peer review practices visible helps readers understand the quality assurance processes behind scholarly books

A French version of this blog post is available on the OpenEdition blog. Une version française de cet article de blog est disponible sur le blog d’OpenEdition.

Last month, Peer Review Week highlighted the importance of sustaining quality assurance in scholarly communication. With Open Access Week last week, there is an opportunity to consider a closely connected question: how can we make not only scholarly research, but also the processes that underpin its publication, more visible and accessible?

For scholarly books, transparency is one practical place to start. Peer review practices vary across disciplines, regions and publishing models, reflecting different scholarly traditions and publishing contexts. Making these practices more visible can help readers, researchers, libraries and funders better understand the processes behind the books they encounter.

This is the context in which the Peer Review Information Service for Monographs (PRISM) was developed. Managed by the Directory of Open Access Books (DOAB) and a service of OPERAS, PRISM takes a practical approach to one part of the broader challenges facing scholarly communication: making information about peer review practices for scholarly books more visible, structured and reusable. In doing so, it connects two important aspects of scholarly communication: openness in accessing research and transparency about the processes through which it is published.

Why transparency matters

Confidence in scholarly publishing relies not only on the robustness of quality assurance processes, but also on being able to understand them. This is particularly relevant for scholarly books. Books, including open access books, have sometimes been subject to assumptions that they do not undergo rigorous peer review or other robust quality-assurance processes. These perceptions can be especially pronounced in the humanities and social sciences, where books constitute a vital medium for scholarly communication, but they are of course not confined to these disciplines.

There can therefore exist a gap between quality assurance practices set in place by publishers and what is visible to the users – and this is increasingly important in a high-density information environment where users of research encounter large volumes of information and have to navigate between sound scholarly knowledge and mis- and disinformation. 

This is where transparency can help bridge this gap. Of course, it cannot establish the quality or originality of a scholarly work by itself, but it can make us discern the processes behind the work, making them more visible and providing useful additional context for readers, researchers, libraries and funders. The scholarly community needs robust practices, but also means to make underlying practices more understandable and also nuanced. In this way, transparency can help make diversity within book publishing visible without turning diversity into a hierarchy.

Benefits of PRISM across the scholarly ecosystem

PRISM can make a practical contribution to the scholarly ecosystem as the service was developed in response to the need to make peer review and quality-assurance practices around scholarly books more visible.

By providing a standardised way to display information about peer review procedures at both publisher and publication level, it makes information about the peer review processes presented by publishers more visible, structured, reusable, and therefore more discoverable. It is not a certification tool and as such does not certify that a book has been rigorously peer reviewed, assess the quality of an individual peer review, or rank different peer review models.

Integrated within DOAB, this information can also be made available as structured information within the wider scholarly communication ecosystem.

In doing so, PRISM can also help counter assumptions that books – and particularly open access books – are published without rigorous quality assurance. 

What information does PRISM provide?

One way to understand PRISM is through five simple questions – what,who, how, when, and who:

  1. What is being reviewed? For example, a proposal, a full manuscript or a section.
  2. Who conducts the review? This might be an internal editor, a member of an editorial board, an external peer reviewer or participants in an open review process.
  3. How is the review conducted in terms of anonymity? For example, identities may be known to both parties, or the author and reviewer may be anonymised to one another.
  4. When does the review take place? For example, before or after publication.
  5. Who is responsible for the publication decision? Depending on the publisher’s process, this responsibility may rest with the publisher, a books or series editor, or a scientific or editorial board.

PRISM can also describe whether review comments are published, adding further information to ensure transparency around the process . This information can be provided for a publisher’s different peer review processes and associated with individual books, helping users see both the approaches a publisher uses and the process reported for a particular title. See DOAB’s Publishers’ Guide.

The kind of transparency about peer review that PRISM represents can provide value to different stakeholders in different ways, as depicted by the four images below. 

Working together across the ecosystem

The wider challenges identified during Peer Review Week cannot be solved by one stakeholder group alone,  but is a collective responsibility, vital for safeguarding the scholarly ecosystem against questionable science and preventing negative downstream impacts on public trust and future research. Researchers, publishers, editors, funders, policymakers, libraries, and scholarly infrastructures all have different roles to play. 

The value of this collective effort increases when information can move across the ecosystem. PRISM’s structured information and controlled vocabularies support interoperability and create opportunities for metadata aggregators, discovery services and other scholarly platforms to reuse peer review information.

Looking ahead

Questions about how to sustain quality, support reviewers and strengthen transparency continue to shape scholarly communication: How can we manage growth without compromising quality? How can we support and recognise reviewers? How can technology help without replacing meaningful human judgement? How can we strengthen transparency while respecting the diversity of scholarly publishing practices?

These are questions that cannot be answered by any one part of the scholarly ecosystem as peer review is a shared scholarly craft and sustaining that craft is a shared responsibility. The answers will also look different from the perspectives of different disciplines, publishing models, and communities.

In this particular context, we have focused on transparency in peer review for scholarly books and how PRISM supports a more transparent ecosystem in which different approaches can be understood. As open access expands and scholarly content reaches increasingly diverse audiences, making these practices visible and understandable becomes increasingly important.

Discover PRISM

Transparency is one practical part of strengthening trust in scholarly communication, and PRISM provides a way for publishers to contribute to that effort. We invite more academic publishers to participate in PRISM and contribute information about their peer review practices to DOAB. We also encourage libraries, funders, researchers, readers, and scholarly infrastructure providers to explore how PRISM information can be used. Learn more about PRISM and how to participate.